Why I Think Star Trek: The Animated Series Should Be Canon

Today is the 60th Anniversary of the original Star Trek making it past two pilots, a failed early pitch, and finally making it onto television. Airing for only three seasons on NBC, it only stayed that long to make syndicated reruns possible, and that still required a fan outcry. The show would gain more fans, lead to a failed new series that became Star Trek: The Motion Picture, whose opening song became the theme song for Star Trek: The Next Generation.

In between those events, NBC wanted more Star Trek, but turned to animation. The plan was to make an hour long series, but the network opted for a half-hour Saturday morning series to be cheap. Plus kids liked Star Trek. Partnering with Filmation, the show would bring back old writers, most of the cast (Leonard Nimoy fought for most of the cast when they just wanted him, William Shatner, and DeForest Kelley, but either didn’t fight for Walter Keening or couldn’t get him involved–so he wrote an episode instead), revisit some of their episodes, and chart new adventures for the crew of the starship Enterprise.

For reasons I’ve never heard, Gene Roddenberry didn’t consider it canon, and neither did Paramount for many years. I’m not even sure they do now, so I was surprised to see it show up in the tribute video. So did Lower Decks but if Prodigy was there I missed it. It doesn’t air on any other network or streaming option except for MeTV Toons, what the Boomerang network should have remained. None of the Pluto TV Star Trek or science fiction channels carry it, nor is it on demand there. I can watch all the pre-Kurtzman shows and movies, even the Abrams movies, but not Star Trek: The Animated Series.

I know Hollywood doesn’t care about animation. It’s either “kiddie crap” or subversive adult actual crap. However, they should get over their biases and this show is a good reason why. Since it’s also the animated show’s anniversary (we’re the same age!), allow me to explain.

Continue reading

BW’s Daily Video> Pacing And Narrative Drive

Catch more from SF Debris on his website because YouTube is a pain

Also, this was recorded after a tornado hit his neighborhood. No injury reports but also no electricity and a lot of smashed trees. Hence the impromptu nature. This has been in the buffer for a bit.

Chapter By Chapter> Star Trek: The IDIC Epidemic chapter 12

Chapter By Chapter (usually) features me reading one chapter of the selected book at a time and reviewing it as if I were reviewing an episode of a TV show or an issue of a comic. There will be spoilers if you haven’t read to the point I have, and if you’ve read further I ask that you don’t spoil anything further into the book. Think of it as a read-along book club.

In the previous chapter, we saw an attempted date go horribly wrong, and it couldn’t happen to a bigger jerk. It did give us a chance to explore the philosophy of the Followers Of T’Vet, and the author got to play with Vulcan mating habits and biology for a bit. Now we’re returning to Nisus and Korsal the Klingon. Don’t worry, the usual cast will be here soon enough. I hope.

Quick shoutout to the Spacebattles forum (yes, my stats told me you were talking about me behind my back again…hi!) and specifically Dragolord09 for linking to the first chapter of this review. Appreciate it. One of the other posters commented that making Nisus an unaligned colony makes it look like a “super-special colony that’s outside the Federation is really just the Federation, and it kind of ruins the suspension of disbelief”. It’s not the first time we’ve seen colonies or transporters not officially aligned with the Federation or the other Alpha Quadrant throughout the franchise, both officially and in fan projects like Star Trek: Intrepid. (I need to follow up on that someday. Darn backlog!) The books tend to exist somewhere between those two designations.

I think the reason Jean Lorrah chose to set it in such a place was to include races that normally wouldn’t be allowed to take part, either by the Federation/Starfleet or by their own planets. We have the Klingons who recently left, sans Korsal who is acting as a representative. I think Romulans were mentioned but I could be wrong. Our book-exclusive guest cast also includes Borth, an Orion looking to weaponize the plague and sell it to the Klingons as a bio-weapon since thus far they appear to be immune, or at least Korsal and his mixed species children are currently. Who knows what will happen if the plague mutates again. Korsal stated that Klingons would never do something so dishonorable, but I suspect this will come up again. (Also, what’s the Duras family like in this period? I wouldn’t put it past the sisters from the next century, but it’s been a while.)

As we saw in The Vulcan Academy Murders (previously reviewed), Lorrah likes to play with various races as part of exploring the conflict between them. Setting the story primarily where those races can best interact, like the Vulcan Science Academy that isn’t tied to the Federation despite working with them, or the Nisus science colony gives her open territory to build up that conflict, especially given what little we already know about the plague, and some currently unknown connection to the children before the Andorian who made the discovery died from it. The point is more about the potential for personal conflict that making it super-special. Gives her more toys to play with. And one of those toys is heading home, so let’s check in with our Klingon and half-Klingon.

Continue reading

BW’s Daily Video> Please Stop Letting Narcissists Write Superheroes

Catch more from JesterBell on YouTube

 

Jake & Leon #696> Sorting War

We’re also forgetting that Jake’s furniture is mostly made of comic storage boxes. Plus comics take up less space on their own than videos.

At least it’s done, even though it took me a week after to be able to make this comic and do a quick report on the home video inventory for this week’s Clutter Report. You’ll also notice I got this week’s Golden Age comic review in. If you didn’t, check the previous post.

As I write this I’m actually ahead of schedule in my writing, not counting buffer articles like fillers and evergreen article series. I’m at half count there for my minimum. If I can get my buffers going I’ll have a nice bit of break potential. There should be another Chapter By Chapter installment for Star Trek: The IDIC Epidemic plus whatever else comes up that isn’t sorting videos and disks. Have a great week, everyone!

“Yesterday’s” Comic> Science Comics #3

You can’t have too much fire to burn these things with…but we gonna try!

Science Comics #3

Fox Publications, Inc (April, 1940)

I guess this one has been doing okay so far, given that it’s on the continue reading list. Not that any of these characters are all that memorable, going back to a discussion earlier this week on why some characters make it and why they’re worth defending. Should any of these forgotten heroes gotten a second chance? Let’s find out.

[Read along with me here]

Continue reading

Saturday Night Showcase> Transformers: Rescue Bots With Cullen AND Curry

I said this is how last week’s Peter Cullen and Tim Curry tribute fest should have ended.

Rescue Bots is the outlier in the “aligned continuity”, a poorly named period in Transformers media history as nothing was aligned. Between all four productions–the War For Cybertron and Fall Of Cybertron game series (including a Nintendo exclusive rail shooter Cybertron Adventures, the Hub series Transformers Prime, this show and its sequel Rescue Bots Academy, and Cartoon Network’s Robots In Disguise, nothing really aligned. Timelines were off, Peter Cullen and Frank Welker were the only actors to be on all of them (minus the Rescue Bot shows, as Megatron never appeared, and Academy as the new animation studio replaced the entire cast), and the designs changed between each of them. Basically, Hasbro set up a way to connect everything, and the usual ego trips by the “smarter than the creators” show makers led to them ignoring everything.

Rescue Bots wasn’t even supposed to be part of the Hub’s side of Transformers. Despite Peter Cullen as Optimus Prime again and Bumblebee’s character growth on Prime being reflected in Rescue Bots, including not being able to talk for most of the series, plus the crossovers between this and Robots In Disguise with Sideswipe and Blurr, the preschool show meant to sell the preschool toys was not intended to be part of the series. Since nobody told them, the show reflected its sister series and became canon by circumstance.

As for Tim Curry, he played Doctor Thaddeus Morocco, one of the few human villains in the franchise I actually like. It’s a short list that includes Circuit Breaker from the Marvel Comics, MECH, and Doctor Archeville from the original series. Yeah, that’s pretty much it. Morocco wanted all the high tech stuff on Griffin Rock, the new technology testing ground where Optimus Prime set up the last team of Rescue Bots to help them learn about their home and potentially open friendly relations with Earthlings. Until they were ready, they remained robots in disguise, pretending to be new rescue equipment under the care of the Burns family, a team of rescue specialists. Closest to them was Cody Burns, too young to do the rescue work but old enough to help Heatwave, Chase, Blades, and Boulder (named for the animation studio? coincidence?) learn more about Earth and its ways.

Sadly, it was during this show that Curry had his stroke, leading to him having to bow out of season two, leading to Jonny Rees taking over for the rest of the original show, but tonight’s story is from season one. Though Prime and Morocco don’t interact, which would have been a better topper to the memorial tribute, they’re both here for the season finale.

In this two part episode, Griffin Rock’s lead scientist, Doctor Green, finds a secret chamber, but Cody finds a chamber within the chamber, holding a time machine. In part one he and Doc Green’s daughter Frankie, Cody’s BFF, are drawn into the past along with the Rescue Bots. When the past is altered, our heroes, joined by Bumblebee and Optimus in one of the rare stories where there’s actual battle (no guns by the heroes though Morocco’s “Morbots” get to have them…doesn’t seem fair), must spend part 2 trying to correct history. Are the Burns’ still heroes in this time period, and how was Cody not born in this reality when the rest of his siblings were?

Enjoy! And rest in peace, Peter Cullen and Tim Curry.

Continue reading