
I was going to do a BW Vs article responding to a couple of articles in Variety about the failures of the Gunnverse Supergirl movie and why Hollywood is failing superheroines. I felt I’d be leaning too close to the culture war by the end and I’m trying to push back in my own way. So I chose a different path: why don’t I want to see it?
Trailers, interviews, preview clips, and backstage video are all supposed to get you hyped to see a movie, to convince you to spend time and money watching the film they’re promoting. All those things convinced me to NOT watch Craig Gillespie and Ann Nogueira’s take on the Maid Of Might as envisioned by James Gunn. Apparently I’m not alone, as the movie is bombing like it was at a party with a free open bar…fitting given that this is based on a Tom King story about Kara going off to get drunk on her birthday by finding a red sun planet with a lower drinking age.
The reviews, including reviews by women like JesterBell and Snarky Jay, have further convinced me to avoid this. The occasional mid rating goes against the more vocal apathy or outright rage, even from people who attacked other reviewers who complained about it. Remember Angry Joe Vargas from the Channel Awesome days, before Mike Michaud ruined the project in the name of tighter controls and ticking off the creators not part of the main videos? He decided to go after members of the Friday Night Tights crew over their complaints about the movie’s promotional info and when they finally got to the theater…only to rage against the movie himself after seeing it. It’s not how I expected two corners of my internet experience to cross paths but there we are. Curious how alt.toys.transformers ends up being part of this. (I’m not against a transforming Supermobile in theory, Hasbro!)
That’s all I’m going to say about that or Milly Alcock’s comments. Some are out of context (though she hasn’t bothered to clarify), some were made to make the…particular social viewpoint website that interviewed her happy during Pride Month, and the rest is the usual nonsense from actors and actresses who care more about what they’re making and who they’re working with than the source material and it’s fans, both of whom are responsible for making the thing you’re being paid more money in an day than I’ve ever had in my bank account to work on. What I haven’t already gone over in past controversies doesn’t fit with this site’s mission.
Instead I’m going to go over all the information I’ve seen and heard about this movie and flat out tell you why I want nothing to do with it or the rest of Gunnverse. There’s a reason this is in the Death Of DC category, and tied to the reason I have that category in the first place.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Why I’m Not Interested In James Gunn’s Supergirl
I was going to do a BW Vs article responding to a couple of articles in Variety about the failures of the Gunnverse Supergirl movie and why Hollywood is failing superheroines. I felt I’d be leaning too close to the culture war by the end and I’m trying to push back in my own way. So I chose a different path: why don’t I want to see it?
Trailers, interviews, preview clips, and backstage video are all supposed to get you hyped to see a movie, to convince you to spend time and money watching the film they’re promoting. All those things convinced me to NOT watch Craig Gillespie and Ann Nogueira’s take on the Maid Of Might as envisioned by James Gunn. Apparently I’m not alone, as the movie is bombing like it was at a party with a free open bar…fitting given that this is based on a Tom King story about Kara going off to get drunk on her birthday by finding a red sun planet with a lower drinking age.
The reviews, including reviews by women like JesterBell and Snarky Jay, have further convinced me to avoid this. The occasional mid rating goes against the more vocal apathy or outright rage, even from people who attacked other reviewers who complained about it. Remember Angry Joe Vargas from the Channel Awesome days, before Mike Michaud ruined the project in the name of tighter controls and ticking off the creators not part of the main videos? He decided to go after members of the Friday Night Tights crew over their complaints about the movie’s promotional info and when they finally got to the theater…only to rage against the movie himself after seeing it. It’s not how I expected two corners of my internet experience to cross paths but there we are. Curious how alt.toys.transformers ends up being part of this. (I’m not against a transforming Supermobile in theory, Hasbro!)
That’s all I’m going to say about that or Milly Alcock’s comments. Some are out of context (though she hasn’t bothered to clarify), some were made to make the…particular social viewpoint website that interviewed her happy during Pride Month, and the rest is the usual nonsense from actors and actresses who care more about what they’re making and who they’re working with than the source material and it’s fans, both of whom are responsible for making the thing you’re being paid more money in an day than I’ve ever had in my bank account to work on. What I haven’t already gone over in past controversies doesn’t fit with this site’s mission.
Instead I’m going to go over all the information I’ve seen and heard about this movie and flat out tell you why I want nothing to do with it or the rest of Gunnverse. There’s a reason this is in the Death Of DC category, and tied to the reason I have that category in the first place.
Continue reading →
Tell others about the Spotlight:
Posted by ShadowWing Tronix on July 2, 2026 in DC Spotlight, Death of DC, Movie Spotlight and tagged commentary, DC Gunnverse, DC Movies, DC movieverse, James Gunn, Supergirl.
Leave a comment